the china room
Travel By Train

"Are there any good guide books?"


Only in China

In no other country will you meet so many travellers talk so much about their guide books. I guess that this has to do with the fact that if you don't speak Chinese (as most of us...) you'll rely heavily on your guide book.

Whatever you do, buying train tickets, shopping, hunting for sights or finding an affordable hotel room, you are pretty much lost in China without a good guide book.

Up to two years ago there was not really a choice in that matter, because there was only one book catering for the needs of individual travellers in China. Lonely Planet had the market cornered and their China Survival Kit was simply "The Book" with the travellers in China.

Two books for the country

Last year (1997) the first real contender showed up: The Rough Guides came out with their China guide.

This year (1998) I travelled with the Rough Guide, and while it is still a bit rough around the edges (excuse the pun), it is really not bad. The Lonely Planet is still superior with its maps and the sheer number of hotels it lists, but I especially liked the way the Rough Guide presents the sights along the way.

A choice or what?

It's a tie! I really don't know what to recommend here. The new edition of the Lonely Planet Survival Kit (June 1998) lists more stuff and is now about a year ahead, but the Rough Guide is strong in describing the sights and has an interesting way to organize the different destinations in China in groups or areas rather than the stricter province-by-province listing that the Lonely Planet uses.

Well, it's probably best if you take a look at both in the book shop and take the one you like more. Both will get you through China - and there are always travellers with the other guide around to cross-check the descriptions and addresses.

 
the china room  -  travel in china  -  my travelogues  -  china info  -  china links  -  www.sturm.to  -  email
(C) 1996-2007 Thomas Sturm